|
"'The fascination of the volume is its concentration on Shalt=ut's work as an interpreter of the Qur'an and a scholar of jurisprudence.'
Jorgen S. Nielsen, Centre for the Study of Islam and Christian-Muslim Relations, Birmingham, Reviews in Religion and Theology, August 1994"
"'a detailed, in-depth study of his life and thought ... The study is based on careful, detailed, and exhaustive research and is likely to remain the authoritative work on Shalm=ut for some time to come ... written in a style that is readily accessible to non-specialists.'
M. Swartz, Boston University, Choice, May '94"
"'Zebiri has provided us with a very important study on the modernist `Ulama', especially Muhammad 'Abduh's legacy ... The book fills a gap in that direction and in answering why the modernist 'ulama' have not succeeded in modernizing and also why they have not failed.'
Ahmad S. Moussalli, American University of Beirut, Journal of Islamic Studies, Vol. 6, No. 1, 1995"
"The overall thesis is clear and convincing ... Specialists in religion and jurisprudence will appreciate Zebiri's detailed attention to Quranic exegesis and modern interpretations of the sharia ... this carefully argued monograph has made an important start in a neglected field and provides a solid basis on which other studies can build." - International Journal of Middle East Studies
"She propounds a learned comparative study intended to clarify the similarities and divergences between Shaltut's exegesis, on the one hand, and that of `Abduh, on the other. The author demonstrates her grasp of this important field by comparing Shaltut's tafsir with other contemporary ones." - British Journal of Middle Eastern Studies
"...Zebiri is to be congratulated for her summaries of Shaltut's style and his use of sources. Zebiri's overall assessment of Shaltut is sober and fair. Her book is clealy written and interesting, critical and sympathetic...it would make an excellent textbook for students at many levels." - Bulletin of the School of Oriental and African Studies
|